Evelyn Collection

A refined twist on a nostalgic classic. Our Seasonal Thumbprints feature a soft, buttery cookie with delicately crisp edges and a melt-in-your-mouth center. Each filled with small-batch, flavor-forward jams and spreads that celebrate the best of the season from Ordinary Evelyn's.

Choose from three handcrafted fillings:

• Pumpkin Butter – Smooth, warmly spiced, and cozy as a crisp fall morning.
• Rhubarb & Strawberry Jam – Bright, tangy-sweet, and beautifully balanced; made in collaboration with Ordinary Evelyn’s.
• "Home for the Holidays" (Cranberry Jam) – Vibrant, tart, and festive—an elevated nod to holiday nostalgia.

Order a mixed box to enjoy all three seasonal flavors, or buy a box with your favorite jam flavor to keep the one you love most all to yourself.

Perfect for gifting, gatherings, or savoring with a warm drink in hand.